Vincent Lancisi founded Everyman Theatre in 1990 in a chilly Baltimore church. He plans to retire in June at the end of its 35th season — but not before directing two more plays. “Theater matters when it is shared,” he said. Photo courtesy of Everyman Theatre

• Share

PRINT

Vincent M. “Vinny” Lancisi has never been one for grand flourishes. For more than three decades, the founder and artistic director of Baltimore’s Everyman Theatre has preferred the steady rhythm of rehearsal rooms and the slow craft of building a talented ensemble.

The recent announcement of Lancisi’s retirement at the end of the 2025-26 season, which is the 35th anniversary of the theater he founded, drops the curtain on a remarkable voice in Baltimore’s cultural life. Although Lancisi will direct two of Everyman’s six plays this season, he will step away next June after a career that transformed a scrappy startup in a drafty church into one of the city’s most enduring artistic institutions.

“Now I start a new journey where I discover what life is like if I don’t have to go to work every day,” Lancisi told the Beacon.

“The keys to a happy retirement are to celebrate the go-go years during the slow-go years before the no-go years.”

A collaborative outlook

The youngest in a Boston family of seven, Lancisi learned early that being the voice of quiet persuasion helps stand out in the crowd while sustaining energy for the long haul.

He reapplied that knowledge years later while studying theater at Boston College and later Catholic University, where he earned an MFA in directing, all the while dreaming of establishing a small, professional theater company in an artistic niche that wasn’t being filled.

He found that space in Baltimore. Everyman’s story began in 1990 in Saint John’s Church in Charles Village. Lancisi, fresh out of graduate school, launched a fledgling troupe there with no budget to speak of and little insulation. During the company’s inaugural production, Lancisi handed out blankets so patrons could keep warm.

From those makeshift beginnings Lancisi grew his vision of an actor-centered company rooted in accessibility. He insisted on affordable tickets to “great stories, well told” — the theater’s motto. This set Everyman apart in a city already crowded with theaters.

As Lancisi likes to say, “Theater is a collaboration — a long conversation with the city you serve.”

That philosophy imbues every aspect of Everyman productions, which aren’t for an elite few, but for the community that gathers in its seats and unites when the lights go down.

“Theater shows that we still seek each other out, need public discourse, share a common condition,” Lancisi said. “In fact, studies have shown the heart rates of the audience members and the actors sync during a performance. That is how powerful theater is.”

Inspired by classic repertory models, Lancisi built a resident company of artists that remains a rarity in regional theater. Actors can return, grow and connect with audiences over time.

“I set out to create a group of professional actors and designers who could see Everyman as their artistic home. They didn’t have to go off to New York or L.A. to make a living practicing their craft; they could stay right here in the Baltimore/D.C. area, and they could consistently have work throughout the season at Everyman,” he said in a 2014 interview.

“Our audiences love seeing how our actors can transform from one role to the next.”

A turning point

Over the next two decades, Everyman inched from survival to stability. There were lean years and whispered doubts, but Lancisi proved as adept at fundraising and diplomacy as at directing.

In 2013, critical support from donors and civic partners helped the company secure a permanent home: a former 1911 vaudeville house on Fayette Street, which was restored into a 253-seat theater. That move marked Everyman’s coming of age.

The Bromo/Westside district has since become Everyman’s neighborhood, and Lancisi its caretaker. He has directed dozens of productions, from intimate chamber plays to sprawling family dramas, always willing to try something new.

“If you are learning, you are living,” he said.

Everyman’s next season

In Everyman’s current season of celebration and farewell, the lineup promises a distillation of the company’s identity: ensemble work, contemporary voices and local flavor. Its season includes August Wilson’s The Piano Lesson, Jane Austen’s Emma and the Tony Award-winning comedy Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike, which Lancisi will direct next spring.

In the meantime, the succession process is underway. Everyman is committed to preserving the ensemble ethos as new leadership takes the reins.

At the same time, the theater has launched a Founders Circle fundraising campaign, inviting patrons to invest in Everyman’s future.

Director takes a seat

For Lancisi, theater was truly an every day, seven-day-a-week (and some nights) endeavor of love. Next summer, the other loves of his life — his wife, Robin, and two cats — may not know what to do with him.

Lancisi looks forward to enjoying productions as an audience member, although it may take some adjustment to relinquish control and simply be entertained.

“Now it’s my turn to experience catharsis through storytelling without worrying about the logistics of production,” he said.

Lancisi’s departure will be felt throughout the city’s arts ecosystem, perhaps most by Everyman’s actors and staff who stayed during the lean years.

Lancisi’s unique brand of management and magic combines three principles, he said: “continuity, generosity and the belief that theater matters when it is shared.”

He has made theater matter in his adopted city of Baltimore, filled with “distinct neighborhoods and authentic voices just waiting to tell their stories,” he said. “In Baltimore, theater can be a home, a habit and a mirror for the community it serves.”

After his final production in 2026, the applause will be for more than a single man. It will be for the small theater that emerged in this city to tell its stories.

In theater, the art of making an entrance and exit is analogous to learning how to transition through life.

“Nobody teaches the business of theater. And nobody teaches the business of life after theater,” he said.

For the full list of Everyman Theatre’s upcoming plays, see everymantheatre.org/plays-events/2025-2026, email boxoffice@everymantheatre.org or call (410) 752-2208.