What should you do about Medigap?
When we reach 65, that magic age of Medicare eligibility, we have some serious financial decisions to make about getting supplemental coverage. But there’s the alphabet soup of plan options, the complexity of what’s covered and what’s not, and the challenge of figuring out what Future You is going to need.
“It is 100 percent overwhelming,” said Kevin Moss, senior editor at the nonprofit Consumers’ Checkbook. “It’s such a consequential decision: It forces you to think about what you need right now, what you will need in five or 10 years, and what you will need all the way to the end of your life.”
Getting care through traditional or original Medicare can be expensive, which is why most beneficiaries who choose it over a private Medicare Advantage plan opt for an added private policy, known as Medicare Supplement Insurance or, more colloquially, Medigap.
Medigap vs. Medicare Advantage
There are essentially two major paths you can take when you are choosing supplemental Medicare coverage.
One is Medigap, and the good news is that most people like it. In one 2023 study, 93% of beneficiaries said they were happy with their choice, with 80% saying they were either “very” or “extremely” satisfied.
The other is Medicare Advantage — not quite as beloved, with 73% saying they are satisfied with their current plan, according to an AARP survey. Medicare Advantage plans are a private insurance alternative to traditional Medicare that typically charge modest (or even no additional) premiums and include prescription drug coverage. They often have extras, like coverage of vision and dental.
Others go with traditional Medicare, which doesn’t have limits on providers and has fewer requirements for prior authorizations. However, out-of-pocket costs can be much higher, so many traditional Medicare beneficiaries add a Medigap plan, which you can think of as a wrapper around the traditional Medicare plan.
For that, you pay additional premiums (which range from $50 to $300 a month, in addition to the standard 2026 $202 monthly Part B premium).
Keep in mind traditional Medicare does not cover prescription drugs, for which you will need a standalone Part D policy at an added cost.
Pairing Medigap with traditional Medicare means you get help with out-of-pocket costs and can see any of the 98% of doctors who accept Medicare.
“With Medigap you can start right away when you’re 65 with no underwriting, which is so important to people with underlying conditions,” said Sally Greenberg, CEO of the National Consumers League.
“Basically you can go to whatever doctor you want and can sign up for any Medigap plan you choose. That’s pretty good.”
Alphabet soup
If you choose the Medigap path, that’s only the first step. Then you must choose from 10 standardized levels of plans: A, B, C, D, F, G, K, L, M, N. These are administered at the state level, so the policies you are offered depend on your location; insurers might offer some, but not all.
That’s a lot of letters, so to help narrow those down: Almost all Medigap enrollees are in Plans F or G, which are the most comprehensive options. Each of those plans amounts to 41% of Medigap policyholders. Plan N (and its lower premiums) is the third most popular at 11%.
Another thing to know: Different insurers charge different premiums for the same plan, which is why shopping around is critical.
They also may raise rates differently. One analysis last year found, for example, that larger insurers implemented larger increases.
Timing is key
The timeline is to first get Medicare Part A (which covers hospital charges) and Part B (doctors), and then consider a Medigap plan.
There is a limited time window for getting Medigap done with no underwriting. This is known as “guaranteed issue,” and it applies for the first six months after you become eligible for Medicare (typically age 65).
“This is a one-time opportunity that does not repeat,” said Nancy Ochieng, a senior policy analyst with KFF. “If you miss that window, you can be charged higher premiums or be denied a Medigap policy.”
Do your research before turning 65 so you don’t get caught flat-footed — as much as 18 months beforehand.
Where to turn
Given the complexity of the subject and the volume of information about Medigap plans, how can you make sense of it all? A few places to start:
State Health Insurance Assistance Programs: When it comes to plan particulars, it’s state-level information you want, since that’s where programs are administered. For free advice in Maryland, call (410) 767-1100; in D.C., call (202) 727-8370; and in Virginia, call (800) 552- 3402.
Medicare Plan Finder: This is a helpful federal site (medicare.gov/plan-compare) for walking you through supplemental coverage options. Enter your ZIP code and get an immediate display of Medigap plan options available, from A through N.
MedPAC: MedPAC advises Congress on Medicare policy. To learn what plans are most popular, a breakdown of benefits, how premiums are set and so on, check out the “Preliminary Work on Medigap” presentation at medpac.gov.
Independent reviews: Some financial information sites rate Medigap plans. NerdWallet recently outlined its picks for 2025 (Overall winner: AARP/United Healthcare).
ValuePenguin makes suggestions based on plan type, rather than particular companies. Its selection for most people: Plan G.
The annual Medicare Open Enrollment Period runs from October 15 to December 7. That’s when you can make changes to your coverage, such as switching to a Medicare Advantage plan, enrolling in or dropping a Part D plan or switching back to Original Medicare.
This article first appeared in Kiplinger Retirement Report.
© 2025 The Kiplinger Washington Editors, Inc. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.