Non-drug therapies needed for dementia
The human and financial cost of Alzheimer’s disease is devastating. More than 55 million people are living with Alzheimer’s disease and other causes of dementia, rising to 78 million by 2030 and 139 million by 2050.
In the United States alone, the Alzheimer’s Association estimated that in 2020, more than 11 million unpaid caregivers provided 15.3 billion hours of assistance (valued at $256.7 billion) to 6.2 million people with dementia. That estimate does not include the $51.2 billion in Medicaid payments for Americans ages 65 and older living with dementia.
Drugs to slow Alzheimer’s
For years, most Alzheimer’s clinicians, researchers and advocacy groups have pinned their hopes on a pharmaceutical solution to this crisis, yet there has been failure after failure.
Last year, amid considerable professional debate, the FDA approved the first medication thought to be able to slow the accumulation of Alzheimer’s disease pathology in the brain.
The theory, as yet unproven, is that if such a drug is given early enough — before there are any symptoms — the disease progression will be so gradual that people will be able to live out their lives without developing disabling dementia.
A looming crisis
Although this hoped-for trajectory is logical and laudable, the immediate effect may be costly. The vast majority of new medications being developed for Alzheimer’s disease — including the one the FDA approved — are being evaluated in people who already have symptoms, such as memory loss.
These new disease-modifying drugs will therefore first be used in millions of individuals with mild Alzheimer’s symptoms. Because these drugs slow down (but not stop) the accumulation of pathology, individuals with symptomatic Alzheimer’s disease will continue to progress, and — if the therapies are successful — they will progress more slowly.
Instead of the mild stage of dementia lasting about three years, it might last four to six years. Instead of the moderate stage lasting about four years, it might last five to seven years. This means that, for the foreseeable future, disease-modifying drugs will not decrease the numbers of individuals living with dementia — it will actually hugely increase them.
For this reason, it is critical that the U.S. and other countries invest in not only pharmacological but also nonpharmacological treatments for Alzheimer’s disease and other dementias.
Although many strategies have been developed to improve memory in those patients with mild memory symptoms, few, if any, of these interventions have undergone large clinical trials to prove (or disprove) their efficacy.
One study from a group of Boston researchers examined 32 individuals with mild memory problems, half with mild cognitive impairment and half with mild Alzheimer’s disease dementia.
They found that both groups improved their memory by simply thinking about the following question when learning new information: “What is one unique characteristic of this item or personal experience that differentiates it from others?”
Another study by Boston researchers found that 19 individuals with mild cognitive impairment could improve their ability to remember items at a virtual supermarket by simply thinking systematically about whether items were already in their cupboard before putting them in their shopping cart.
Larger studies are needed, however, to determine if such memory strategies are generalizable.
Role for music, pets, robots
Similarly, there are many nonpharmacological treatments that appear to provide comfort and reduce agitation in individuals with moderate to severe dementia. But larger and more rigorous studies are needed to prove or disprove their efficacy and thereby promote more widespread utilization.
- A group of Portuguese clinicians and researchers reviewed more than 100 studies evaluating music-based interventions for people with dementia who had agitation or other behavioral and psychological symptoms of dementia, finding that the vast majority were efficacious with few or no side effects.
- A team of neurologists from Florida reviewed the effects of dog therapy and ownership, finding that both were safe and effective approaches to treat chronic and progressive neurological disorders.
- Other researchers found reductions in anxiety and psychoactive medication use when robot pets were given to individuals with dementia.
- A review of the built environment (the architecture of the home or facility) concluded that “specific design interventions are beneficial to the outcomes of people with dementia.”
Education for families
Educating families and other caregivers about how to manage the different stages and facets of dementia is also critical.
One pilot study by Brazilian clinicians invited caregivers to participate in educational sessions and found a high rate of program satisfaction. Unfortunately, these types of caregiver education interventions are rarely studied in large clinical trials.
Enormous potential savings
If strategies in the mild stages prove effective enough to save just one hour each week of a caregiver’s time for the roughly two million people in the U.S. with mild dementia, it could save 104 million hours valued at $1.7 billion each year.
That extra hour might, for example, allow a “sandwiched caregiver” to help their child with homework while their parent with mild dementia takes medications or pays bills independently.
If nonpharmacologic interventions in the moderate to severe stages saved just one month of nursing home care for the roughly four million people with moderate to severe dementia in the U.S., it would save more than $31 billion dollars (based on a semi-private nursing home room costing $93,075 per year).
And that financial savings is in addition to the social and emotional benefit to individuals with Alzheimer’s disease and their families.
New models of reimbursement
Finally, once nonpharmacological treatments have been proven efficacious, new models of reimbursement will be needed to pay for their implementation, as traditional insurance payments are geared toward medications.
The only way the U.S. — and the world — will be able to cope with the rising numbers of people with dementia will be for nonpharmacological approaches to be used along with pharmacological therapies.
Andrew E. Budson, M.D., is a contributor to Harvard Health Publications.
© 2022 Harvard University. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.