Over 400,000 Monthly Readers
IN FOCUS FOR PEOPLE Over 50
  • Home
  • Health
  • Money
  • Travel
  • Arts
  • Tech
  • Cover Stories
  • Housing
  • From the Publisher
  • Silver Pages Directory
  1. Home
  2. Arts

Arts

SEARCH Arts

A solution to the older driver conundrum

Photo by motionlantern on Vecteezy
  • Share
PRINT
By Bob Levey
Posted on May 12, 2022

He was an 80-year-old behind the wheel of an SUV. In March, he became the centerpiece of a major disaster — and a major controversy.

The driver lost control of his vehicle on a sunny weekday. He smashed into diners having lunch outside the Parthenon Restaurant in Northwest Washington. Two diners were killed and nine others were seriously injured.

No one has fully explained how the crash happened — not the authorities, and not the driver himself. Maybe he mistook the accelerator for the brake? Maybe he had a medical emergency? Not clear.

Regardless, the aftermath resurfaced an issue that has divided the senior community and their relatives for decades: Should an octogenarian still have a driver’s license?

And if you vote yes, should he or she be re-tested regularly to see if he/she still has the requisite abilities behind the wheel?

So many seniors see this issue as a matter of rights. To revoke their license — or require re-testing — would limit their mobility, their social lives, their easy access to shopping and healthcare.

“Why, who are these young whippersnappers who want us to go quietly into oblivion, or into a taxi or a bus?” they ask. “We have the same rights to drive a motor vehicle as anyone else!”

Re-testing seniors only would be a double standard, this line of reasoning argues. Either re-test everyone or no one.

On the other side are what I call the Practical People.

They insist that they are not trying to cancel any senior’s rights. But they quickly add that seniors may be the worst judges of how poor their reflexes, their eyesight and their awareness have become. Safety, the Practical People argue, is everyone’s job.

The controversy has never come close to being resolved. It won’t be easily resolved after the Parthenon horror, either.

But here’s an idea that both sides should consider: Voluntary re-testing.

Drivers above a certain age — let’s say 70, for the sake of argument — would agree to be re-tested on or near each birthday. They would agree ahead of time to accept a negative result.

The re-test would be much more rigorous than the once-over-lightly exam we all took when we first got a license, all those decades ago. The re-test would put the driver inside a simulator with a wheel and pedals.

The simulator would serve up video of actual traffic conditions. Besides measuring how long it takes to brake in an emergency, the re-test would peg peripheral vision and visual acuity in bad weather or darkness.

A sub-par result, as pre-determined by medical experts, would cancel a license on the spot.

Yes, this may sound harsh. But my hunch is that many seniors might embrace it as a way of providing extra safety for everyone.

Yes, losing a license might impose economic hardship on some seniors. If they still work, a car might be the only convenient passport to that workplace and that income.

But public transportation is vastly more available and more reliable than it once was. Meanwhile, volunteer organizations have sprung up to offer free rides to seniors caught in just such a situation.

Yes, losing a license might cause isolation and depression among seniors suddenly denied the right to drive. But both of those can be overcome by shoe leather, therapy and will.

Yes, voluntary re-testing would drive up the costs of running a motor vehicle bureau. But compare that to the costs that accompany a disaster — emergency services, medical care, insurance claims, possible lawsuits, lost human life. It isn’t close.

Finally, voluntary re-testing would produce what is so often missing in the modern world — a nice, warm feeling.

Imagine a senior who voluntarily re-tests — and aces the test. The test-giver would offer a sticker — similar to the I VOTED sticker we get on Election Day.

The sticker could say I AM STILL A SAFE DRIVER. Or maybe I PASSED MY DRIVER’S TEST WITH FLYING COLORS. Or maybe KISS ME — I’M A RE-TESTED DRIVER.

Regardless, a re-tested driver can look in the mirror and say without question: “Other people matter to me. Other people deserve to be protected from accidents. I have done my part, voluntarily. I have done it without kicking, screaming or denying.”

Many mountains need to be moved before voluntary re-testing is required. Rather than wait, I’ve decided to re-take the standard test on my next birthday.

See you in line at the motor vehicle bureau. Kisses optional.

Bob Levey is a national award-winning columnist.   

Arts 2022

  • January
  • February
  • March
  • April
  • May

#Gardening #Bibliophile #Toby's Dinner Theatre #Baltimore #richmond #Pruning

2021
Arts Archive

2022Mont. Co.

SENIORS' RESOURCE GUIDE

Click here to see the 2022 Seniors' Resource Guide.

Silver PagesDirectory

FIND WHAT YOU NEED, FAST.

This comprehensive, searchable directory covers
housing, homecare, elder law and financial planning

CommunityEvents

A CALENDAR JUST FOR YOU

Find fun, interesting, informative things to do Or post your upcoming event on our website!

Submit PrintClassifieds

ALL PRINT CLASSIFIEDS ARE SUBMITTED ONLINE

Click here to submit your classifieds for one of our upcoming print editions.

Silver PagesDirectory

FIND WHAT YOU NEED, FAST.

This comprehensive, searchable directory covers housing, homecare, elder law and financial planning

Submit PrintClassifieds

ALL PRINT CLASSIFIEDS ARE SUBMITTED ONLINE

Click here to submit your classifieds for one of our upcoming print editions.

CommunityEvents

A CALENDAR JUST FOR YOU

Find fun, interesting, informative things to do Or post your upcoming event on our website!

About the Beacon

Over 50 or love someone who is? Then consider the Beacon your resource for trustworthy information on health, money, technology and travel topics, as well as entertaining features, arts and events.

The Beacon’s award-winning content covers health, financial, technology, housing, travel and arts topics, as well as local events and feature stories. Readers of our four print editions pick up more than 200,000 copies each month at more than 2,400 distribution sites. We also mail copies to subscribers throughout the United States.

Contact Us

THE BEACON NEWSPAPERS

PO Box 2227  •  Silver Spring, MD 20915

WASHINGTON, DC

TEL: 301-949-9766  •  FAX: 301-949-8966

HOWARD COUNTY & BALTIMORE, MD

TEL: 410-248-9101  •  FAX: 301-949-8966

RICHMOND, VA

TEL: 804-673-5203  •  FAX: 301-949-8966

More on our Website

  • About
  • Resource Guide
  • Celebration of the Arts
  • Awards
  • Staff
  • Privacy Policy
  • 2021 50+Expo
  • Recipes
  • Puzzles
  • Cover Stories
  • Community Events
Contact us Classified Form Subscription Form